Truth Beyond Science: The Questions Science Can't Answer

What happens when technology stops serving humanity and begins redefining it?

In this episode of Brave New Us, Samantha Stephenson sits down with Dr. John Grabowski, professor of moral theology and ethics at The Catholic University of America and author of A Catholic Guide to Being Human.

Their conversation explores Christian anthropology in an age of artificial intelligence, transhumanism, reproductive technology, and gender ideology. Together they discuss why science is not the same as scientism, why technology is never entirely neutral, and how the Church's understanding of the human person provides a compelling alternative to today's culture of self-creation.

They also examine the ethics of life extension, CRISPR, designer children, contraception, and the relationship between the body, identity, and personhood—drawing on Scripture, Theology of the Body, C.S. Lewis, and Pope St. John Paul II.

In This Episode

  • Why Dr. Grabowski wrote A Catholic Guide to Being Human

  • Science versus scientism

  • The technological imperative

  • AI and whether tools are ever morally neutral

  • The promises and pitfalls of transhumanism

  • Therapy versus enhancement in medicine

  • CRISPR, longevity, and life-extension ethics

  • Why children are meant to be begotten, not made

  • Contraception and the transhumanist impulse

  • Gender ideology and "the body as screen"

  • Modern Gnosticism and today's cultural debates

  • Pope St. John Paul II as an example of authentic humanity

Resources Mentioned

  • A Catholic Guide to Being Human

  • Marriage4Life

  • Angela Franks, Body and Identity

  • Mary Eberstadt, Primal Screams

  • Pope St. John Paul II, Redemptor Hominis

  • Pope Leo XIV, Magnifica Humanitas

  • Subscribe to Samantha's Choosing Human newsletter

Follow Samantha

Newsletter: https://www.choosinghuman.org

Website: https:www.snstephenson.com

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@samanthanstephenson

Chapters

00:00 Science as Truth Judge

00:24 Meet Dr. John Grabowski

01:20 Why This Book Works

05:18 Chapter Eight Focus

06:11 Science Versus Scientism

10:25 Technological Imperative

12:50 AI Not Just Neutral

15:12 Transhumanism Explained

18:24 Life Extension Ethics

23:47 Therapy Versus Enhancement

26:47 Making Versus Begetting

31:25 Designer Children Ethics

32:38 Defining Personhood

34:06 Contraception as Technology

35:47 From Contraception to Identity

39:31 Body as Screen

43:31 Transitioning Realities

46:56 DSM Terms and Treatment

50:58 Gnosticism and Gender

55:17 John Paul II Example

58:58 Resources and Wrap Up

Truth Beyond Science: The Questions Science Can't Answer
Brave New Us